Black Earth History
Patrons' Mercantile Company: The Oldest Farm + Consumer Supply Cooperative in the Nation
by Jennifer Rude Klett, August 2020
In 1894, the oldest farmer/consumer supply cooperative in the nation opened by a few town of Vermont farmers in a rented building in Black Earth after experiencing a depressed economy in the early 1890s. Just three years, the co-op moved to this site, currently the Black Earth Children's Museum at 1131 Mills Street downtown. Fire destroyed the old store in 1933 (shown below in the black and white photo courtesy of the Wisconsin Historical Society), but it was rebuilt that same year. It operated at this site until 1994, according to an historical marker erected by the Dane County Historical Society. In 2000, the co-op merged with Mt. Horeb Farmers Cooperative and the name was changed to Premier Cooperative after major consolidation throughout the area's farming community. The headquarters of Premier Co-op was then moved to Mt. Horeb. The old co-op building in Black Earth was purchased by Aaron and Karen Carlock in 2014. After improving the site, opened as the Black Earth Children's Museum on June 12, 2017.
photo by Jennifer Rude Klett
National Register of Historic Places: Heiney's Meat Market #84003642
by Jennifer Rude Klett, May 2020
The village of Black Earth currently has only one property that is listed on the national register of historic places: Heiney's Meat Market at 1221 Mills Street built in 1869. The former meat market qualified for the register due to its Italianate architecture.
Henry Piper built the home in 1869. David W. Heiney purchased it for $300 in 1888 and made extensive improvements. Heiney first opened the meat market in the basement of the home. In 1911, Heiney built the commercial addition to the north of the family home. Over the next 15 years, Heiney constructed an icehouse, chicken coops, lard-rendering operation, smokehouse and horse barn on land near the building. A brick home was constructed next door in 1922 by David's son Ervin Heiney, just south at the corner of Mills and Park Streets. After David died in 1926, Ervin and his brother Wilford ran the meat market using the family mettwurst and bologna recipes until Ervin retired in the 1960s.
Once the last of the Heiney family passed away in 1967, it was sold to Herman Hoesly and Wendall Anderson and converted to a television repair shop, then sat vacant for some time. In 1977, Carol Schumann and Donna Obright purchased the property to operate an antique shop but after three years renovated it into a cocktail lounge and restaurant called Carodonn's Meat Market Restaurant. The two owners listed the property on the National Register as Heiney's Meat Market in 1984, after the original butcher shop owner. The building was sold in 1990 to Tom and Karen Keyes, who operated it as Keyes West Supper Club. Then, in 1994 it was sold to Scott and Maxine Patchin. The Patchins operated it as David W. Heiney's Dining & Spirits. In 2014, it was converted into apartments.
Other nearby sites on the register:
For information on other local historic sites listed on the National Register of Historic Places, a map may be found at nps.gov, searchable by place. Five other sites near Black Earth include:
-Mazomanie Downtown Historic District #92000406 for 28 buildings of classical revival, Greek revival, and Italian architecture constructed from 1857 to 1942.
-Mazomanie Town Hall #80000126 built from fieldstone in 1878 at 51 Crescent Street.
-Adam Dunlop Farmstead #01001242, established in 1849 on Dunlap Hollow Road in the town of Mazomanie.
-Friederich Kohlmann House #74000075, a Germanic fieldstone/stucco farmhouse established in 1867 on Highway 19 east of Marxville in the town of Berry.
-Frederick Schumann Farmstead #93001426, established in 1878 on Highway 19 in the town of Berry. The Schumann house is a rare example of a true saltbox design in Wisconsin with 18-inch thick walls made with locally-quarried limestone rubble and limestone lintels crowning the doors and windows.
Interested in listing your property?
For information on how to list a property on the register, visit How To List A Property at nps.gov.
sources: nps.gov, wisconsinhistory.org; photo courtesy of the Wisconsin Historical Society
Fickle Municipal Beginnings, Town Formed First
by Jennifer Rude Klett, February 2020
-Town of Black Earth
What is now the town of Black Earth incorporated as part of the town of Farmersville (along with present day Berry & the southern half of Mazomanie townships) on 2 August 1848, just months after Wisconsin became a state. The present-day northern half of Mazomanie township was added to Farmersville days later. Two years later in 1850, Berry was removed to become its own town. Population for Farmersville was 206 people, according to the 1850 census.
The following year in 1851, the town's name was changed from Farmersville to Black Earth. It was only known as Farmersville for about three years. To further complicate the town's origins, the present-day town of Black Earth section split off from the then-larger town of Black Earth in 1858 and called itself Ray township. This was due to a perceived competition between the two railroad villages of Black Earth and Mazomanie existing within the same Black Earth township. It seemed the town wasn't big enough for both. However, this short-sighted split resulted in the village of Mazomanie being surrounded by the town of Black Earth and the village of Black Earth being surrounded by the town of Ray. The next state legislature ended the confusion by re-naming the towns Black Earth and Mazomanie as they exist today, with both villages within their namesake townships. The short-lived town name of Ray only lasted a matter of months.
Today, this explains why the two present townships of Black Earth and Mazomanie are much geographically smaller than most townships in Wisconsin. Will the two towns ever combine again? If so, what should they call themselves? What about Farmersville (again)? In the year 2023, the town of Black Earth will be 175 years old if referring back to the original Farmersville name from 1848.
-Village of Black Earth
The village of Black Earth incorporated in 1857 . . . pretty cut and dried compared to Black Earth township. It was the first incorporated village other than Madison in Dane County. In the year 2032, Black Earth village will be 175 years old.
source: Black Earth: A History
Black Earth Book Still Available:
Black Earth: A History
by Allen Ruff, Ph.D.
A few first edition books are still available from the Black Earth Historical Society for $10.00. Over 50 pages in length with many photographs, the book covers the history of Black Earth from the days of the Ho-Chunk (formerly known as Winnebago) people to the 1992 renovation of the old train depot into a museum by the newly-formed Black Earth Historical Society. Helpful contributors to the book included Irv Simley, Thora Barsness, Roy Sarbacker, Helen Sarbacker, Grace Skalet, Paul Skalet, George Weber, Marion Emerson, Evelyn Cooper, Marilyn Dewitt, Robert Dewitt, David Dybdahl, Adeline Knudtson, Virgil Matz, and Ray Rettenmund. The project took two years with many photographs coming from local family albums. The BEHS would be to happy priority mail you a copy for an additional $7.75.
Prior to European immigration to this area, evidence of Indian settlements dot theBlack Earth Valley. One prominent symbol was a “Man Mound.” This particular mound had a torso oriented east-west and was approximately 100 feet long. The legs were estimated to be about 600 feet and each arm extended in a north-south fashion at an probable length of over 300 feet. The head was twenty-five feet in diameter and, along with the torso, was over five feet high. A house currently resides where the
chest of the effigy mound was located.
The first recorded settlement of European immigrants in the Black Earth valley dates back to 1843. These early settlers were mainly comprised of members of The British Temperance Emigration Society. Approximately twenty immigrants from this Society settled in Black Earth between 1843 and 1850. The first “wave” of English emigrants was followed by Irish and Norwegian settlers, who moved into surrounding locations within the Black Earth valley.
In August of 1850 the village was platted. At that time it consisted of six blocks. Additions were successively made in May 1854, December 1855, and March of 1856, and by 1857 Black Earth had become the first incorporated village in Dane County outside of Madison. George High served as the first president of the village board.
Early on, agriculture and agricultural-related businesses became a prominent fixture of this community. In 1850 John B. Sweat built a grist and flour mill located at the current site of The Shoe Box on the corner of USH 14 and STH 78. During the 1860’s and 1870’s, at its peak, the mill had three runs, and was producing two grades of wheat flour and grist, or cattle feed. By 1858, one year after the Milwaukee & Mississippi Railroad linked the states largest city to the Mississippi River,
Thomas Barber opened a hardware and implement store. It was located at the current site of The Black Earth State Bank.
On April 9, 1894, the Patrons’ Mercantile Company opened its first store at the current location at the corner of Mills and Ray Street. In 1897 it moved to a store at the corner of Spring and Mills Sts. This co-operative, which changed its name to The Patrons’ Mercantile Co-operative in 1960 (name changed to Premier Co-operative in 2001), is the oldest ongoing consumer co-op in the United States, if not the
world. The co-operative was originally established to stabilize the Black Earth economy and to insulate the local markets from wildly unpredictable outside influences. From the beginning the co-operative prospered, with the exception of 1933 when a fire destroyed the store and nearly all of its contents. A new store was built on the same site in less than ten months, and the organization continues to thrive
to this day.
Two other notable businesses to prosper briefly in the village were:
Recreation, historically, has, and still does, play a special role in the village. Home Talent baseball has had a home in this community since the inception of the organization, back in the early 1930’s. Trout fishing along the world-famous Black Earth and Vermont Creeks has been an annual tradition since the 1890’s. During the 1870’s, the Wisconsin Valley Agricultural Society, an organization similar to the Grange, established a local fair. The host site alternated with the neighboring community of Mazomanie. By the turn of the twentieth century another local festival, Field Days, had already been established. With the exception of a brief period during World War II and the late 1950’s, this ongoing celebration has been an annual event.
The Black Earth Historical Society
More recently, August 1992 to be exact, The Black Earth Historical Society was organized. Affiliated with the State Historical Society of Wisconsin, it has two charges: to preserve and to educate the history and inhabitants of the Black Earth valley, respectively.
Since its inception, and with the help of local government, businesses, and citizens,
this Society has restored and refurbished the Black Earth Depot into a local museum.
It is open during the summer months on Sundays 1-4PM and by special appointment.
Ancestral Land Project:
Now Collecting Western Dane County Native American & Settler Stories/Artifacts From 1820 to 1870
-Battle of Wisconsin Heights
-Native American resistance to settlers' land acquisition
-Native American trail marker trees and trails made into roadways
-Significance and preservation of Native American mounds
-Families, marriages, home life, temperance
-Return of Native Americans to ancestral lands after removal
-Cultural significance, lead mining, pow wows in Blue Mounds
-Land claims of Native Americans and settlers
-Geographic corridor between the Wisconsin River and Blue Mounds
-Native American foods and medicines adopted by settlers
For more information, please click here: Ancestral Land Project
Contact: David Stanfield at email@example.com or (608) 767-3449, photo courtesy of David Stanfield
Reprinted in the Wisconsin State Journal on 8 November 2020: